Visa Chargeback Reason Code 10.4: Other Fraud - Card Absent Environment
Visa reason code 10.4 means the card owner denies authorizing or taking part in a card-not-present payment. It can involve online, phone or mail orders. The reply must address that denial. Use a valid rule remedy or proof that links the card owner to the sale.
Why Does Visa 10.4 Occur?
Possible causes include stolen card details, account takeover and a disputed legitimate purchase. An unclear billing name can also cause confusion. The code states the claim. It does not prove its cause.
Check the facts before fighting the case. General Card-not-present fraud checks can reduce risk. Passed checks do not guarantee a win.
Check Authentication and Existing Credits
Ask the payment firm if Visa Secure or another rule protects the payment. Keep the 3D Secure result and linked payment records. The payment must meet the rule's terms and exclusions. A 3D Secure step at checkout is not enough by itself.
If a credit was already issued, include its date, amount and reference. If the card owner withdrew the dispute, retain written confirmation. Complete the provider's response process even when a customer says the matter is resolved.
How Does Compelling Evidence Apply?
Compelling Evidence 3.0, or CE 3.0, uses past purchases and matching data to address the claim. The data must pass set tests. A large file of records is not enough.
Check the Rule Edition and Submission Route
Visa changed the rules for disputes processed from October 24, 2026. The current rules allow qualifying past payments at one or more merchants. The invalid-dispute route excludes Chile. That does not prove every payment firm can match data across sellers.
At pre-arbitration, the acquirer can submit only payment data it accepted and processed. Check the route with the payment firm before using another seller's or processor's records.
Prepare a Prior-Purchase Eligibility Check
- Credential: confirm that the prior payments match the card or an associated payment credential under the applicable rule.
- History: identify two qualifying prior payments and check fraud-report status.
- Dates: validate the required age and lookback limit for the route. The current pre-arbitration route requires prior payments more than 120 days before the dispute was submitted. They must fall within 365 days before its processing date.
- Matching data: compare an eligible device or IP signal with an additional qualifying account, delivery-address or device signal.
- Distinct signals: do not count device ID and device fingerprint as two separate data types.
- Submission: confirm descriptions, data formats and provider support before sending the case.
The current Visa rules, sections 11.8.5.3 and 11.8.5.6, control these conditions. A shared email address or one old purchase does not, by itself, establish CE 3.0 eligibility.
What If the Case Does Not Qualify?
Other allowed proof may still help. Link buyer messages, proof of receipt, pickup records or use logs to the sale. Explain the link to the card owner. Leave out records that do not help.
A fraud claim needs proof that the card owner took part, or another valid remedy. Shipping alone does not prove who placed an order. AVS or CVV results can add context. They do not, by themselves, shift liability.
Hypothetical Evidence Example
An account has two earlier purchases, but the only shared field is an email address. That is an evidence gap, not a completed CE 3.0 test. Check eligible device, IP and other matching fields before selecting that route.
Which Response Deadline Applies?
Visa generally gives the bank 120 calendar days from processing to file a 10.4 claim. That is not the seller's time to reply. Use the provider's due date and leave time to check the proof.
Stripe's response guidance explains its case deadlines. Do not assume every provider gives merchants 30 days.
{{COMPONENT_IDENTIFIER}}
Keep Better Records for Future Claims
- Use a recognizable billing name and clear order confirmations.
- Retain permitted authentication and payment records.
- Connect order, account and fulfillment records consistently.
- Review suspicious orders before fulfillment.
Sources checked November 16, 2026: Stripe's evidence examples and the linked October 2026 Visa rules. Product support and enrollment must be confirmed with the provider.

















